It takes a spot of courage to stand up tall and a bit of derring-do to rise when you fall

Wednesday, November 28, 2007

I'm Just An Ole Cynic At Heart

Tonight I saw a new twist on an old practice. There was a guy walking up and the down the sidewalk in front of some places of business at a strip mall-type place. He had in his hand a can (a large coffee can size) with a slot on the top to put money in. You know the ones----collecting for this and that. It's that time of year. And I know there are many folks in unfortunate situations and it's nice to help out where you can.

Here was the twist, though: this guy's can said, "In Memory Of..." I didn't catch the name, and it had a picture taped to it of a little girl, maybe not even a year old yet. He says, "Can ya help me out. I'm collecting for my daughter's funeral." Now, I have to tell you, that takes the cake. Let's pretend for a minute that this isn't real (ya think??)---how low can you go?? I know, I know---it could be real. A guy could be wandering around in front of Little Caeser's several days after his little girl died, asking for dollars for her funeral. It could happen that way. I, for one, don't buy it. I didn't buy it even for a second. And I think it's pretty slimy (if it's not real and how could it be?) and he's pretty crazy.

But he's crazy like a fox, cuz guess what? Yep, you guessed it: I gave him a dollar.

What a sucker.

cuz.....ya never know.

Well! What would you have done?!

17 Comments:

Blogger jay aitch said...

I'd have whipped out my can and said please help me; I'm saving for MY funeral.

10:38 PM, November 28, 2007

 
Blogger jay are said...

I think we should all just carry our cans around.

11:00 PM, November 28, 2007

 
Blogger Lisa said...

I would have given him a dollar.

No matter what it was for, there's one thing for sure. He needs it more than me. Cause I ain't never gonna stand in front of Little Caesar's with a can.

11:23 AM, November 29, 2007

 
Blogger Lisa said...

PS Nice new picture, junkie!!!

11:24 AM, November 29, 2007

 
Blogger jay are said...

good one, huh?

and if he nets a good score, I might consider the can trick :)

well, maybe not.

11:31 AM, November 29, 2007

 
Blogger Dan said...

You know Jay. The guy must have been desperate to stoop that low (assuming that it wasn't true about his daughter). So I would have felt bad for him and given him a dollar.

Hugs.

1:56 PM, November 29, 2007

 
Blogger jay are said...

I guess that's true...the cynic in me is making a bunch of racket, tho: maybe he just saw a good scam and thought--"hey, here's an easy way to get a buck. I'll never see these people again." But you're right---there's still a level there of...something...and it's a place that I hope I never have the misfortunate of finding myself.

2:13 PM, November 29, 2007

 
Blogger Unknown said...

I, too, would have put a bill in his can—just in case.

10:54 PM, November 29, 2007

 
Blogger Happy Birthday! said...

Hmmm! Did you guys know it's actually somewhat commonplace in some cultures/socioeconomic strata to gather money or ask money for a family member's funeral? Maybe he was from one of those...not saying it wasn't a scam, but just thought I'd add that. On a related note -- I know this isn't the same as holding a can outside a restaurant -- I remember a message board discussion where one group of people was outraged/surprised at the tastelessness, and had never heard of, taking up a collection at work for the funeral of an employee's family member, and an equally outraged/surprised group who had known it as a common practice and thought it was insensitive and beyond tasteless to cast aspersions on the practice. Interesting, huh?

7:30 PM, November 30, 2007

 
Blogger Happy Birthday! said...

shockingly, i'm glad you gave him the dollar too.

7:37 PM, November 30, 2007

 
Blogger Gina said...

I would have given the dollar as well...you never know.

One of my favorite's around my town is, "Why lie I want a beer". Him...NO $$$ from me.

9:21 PM, November 30, 2007

 
Blogger Extrem4 said...

Ok I will be the one person to say I am not giving this guy 1 penny. I was always of the opinion you should give them something that they need not the cash. Hmm .....So maybe give him a .....what? I dont have any spare coffins. Ok maybe a dollar is the easier way out.

5:15 PM, December 01, 2007

 
Blogger Rob said...

I'd have dashed that can from his hands and punched him right in the mouth. Because that's how I roll. Also, it's better to be mistaken than ambiguous, that's what I think...

8:24 PM, December 01, 2007

 
Blogger jay are said...

being lukewarm never gets a guy anywhere.

8:42 PM, December 01, 2007

 
Blogger SoozeSchmooze said...

I think you did the right thing by giving him a buck...I'am not sure why you didn't give him 10 bucks..hee hee....but really in all honesty...if he has the guts to stand out there and ask for money for that reason...and it is not real...well then SHAME ON HIM!!!...NO shame on you if you gave it to him and he was dishonest....I am proud of and trust your first instincts Jay Are

1:47 PM, December 04, 2007

 
Blogger unca said...

Here's a related snippet from one of the Chicken Soup for the Soul books:

Robert De Vincenzo, the great Argentine golfer, once won a tournament and, after receiving the check and smiling for the cameras, he went to the clubhouse and prepared to leave. Some time later, he walked alone to his car in the parking lot and was approached by a young woman. She congratulated him on his victory and then told him that her child was seriously ill and near death. She did not know how she could pay the doctor's bills and hospital expenses. De Vincenzo was touched by her story, and he took out a pen and endorsed his winning check for payment to the woman. "Make some good days for the baby," he said as he pressed the check into her hand. The next week, he was having lunch in a country club when a Professional Golf Association official came to his table. "Some of the boys in the parking lot last week told me you met a young woman there after you won that tournament." De Vincenzo nodded. "Well," said the official, "I have news for you. She's a phony. She has no sick baby. She's not even married. She fleeced you, my friend." "You mean there is no baby who is dying?" said De Vincenzo. "That's right," said the official. "That's the best news I've heard all week," De Vincenzo said.

10:55 AM, December 10, 2007

 
Blogger jay are said...

I remember that one! We've always liked the doctor's attitude about it. Indeed: you mean there's no baby who needs a funeral?? Yay!

10:56 AM, December 10, 2007

 

Post a Comment

<< Home